NARRATIVE INSIGHTS
  • Русский
    • Формировать будущее
  • Cases
    • Shaping the Future
    • Capturing Market Share
    • Reducing Costs on Major Projects
    • Creating Agile Teams
    • Transforming the Banking Sector
    • Shaping the Future of Retail Banking
    • Three Strategies for Combating Amazon
  • About
    • О нас
  • Blog / Блог

“It’s complex.  If you think you have the solution, you’re wrong and dangerous”

5/5/2014

 
Picture
The turnaround in US military fortunes in Iraq in 2006 was attributed to the replacement of bad leaders (Donald Rumsfeld and General Casey) with good ones (Robert Gates and General Petraeus).  But Rumsfeld had left an important legacy with his (inadvertent?) popularisation of the language of complexity.  “There are” he explained at an early press briefing “known knowns; things we know we know.  There are known unknowns; things we know we don’t know.  But there are also unknown unknowns; things we don’t know we don’t know.’  Unfortunately, one of Rumsfeld's (many) mistakes was believing top down leadership was the right answer in all these domains.

'Known knowns’ describe obvious domains that are clear to everyone (if you go to war people will die).  ‘Known unknowns’ describe complicated domains that only few, usually experts, know (how many might die).  While ‘unknown unknowns’ describe what actually occurred - chaos - a place of total randomness.  Yet, the man who finally brought effective leadership to a dire situation - General Petraeus - did so by harnessing  complexity -  the ‘unknown knowns’.  In complex domains we may not know the right answer (for it's constantly changing) or know anyone who does (as answers are widely distributed, with many different people holding small pieces of the bigger puzzle) but we know answers exist, so we must adopt a different mindset to harness and exploit them.

The General, heralded Stateside as the hero of the counter-insurgency, sought answers “further down the ranks, and outside the armed forces entirely, searching for people who had already solved parts of the problem that the US forces were facing.”  He understood that faced with a seemingly intractable problem (as the insurgency seemed in 2006) very different perspectives must be sought.  Petraeus moved away from expert opinion, which anticipates what might happen, to favour instead listening to the experiences of those closest to the action.  This increased awareness of what was happening (replacing uncertainty with certainty) which helped reveal why it was happening and how might an effective response look in context.

Experts can rapidly provide a degree of confidence for leaders faced with difficult challenges.  By collecting masses of data and applying big brains to analyse and synthesise neatly the expert can reduce risk.  But as data is always past data their analysis will be fraught with assumptions extrapolated to determine an unknowable future that will willingly or otherwise confirm their hypothesis - on which their expert status depends. Experts impose what they know and, while their advice can be useful for ‘complicated’ questions, in ‘complex’ domains their advice can mislead - especially if its authority renders other voices mute.  Therefore, as Professor Armstrong of the Wharton School pointed out, when attempting to forecast the future ‘expertise beyond a minimal level is of little value’ so never ‘hire the best expert you can — or even close to the best. Hire the cheapest.’

Title quote attributed to (then) Colonel H.R. McMaster, whose story and some of the other ideas for this blog entry are taken from the excellent 'Adapt: Why success always starts with failure' by Tim Harford


Comments are closed.

    Shape the Future

    Don't just adapt to it

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    April 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    Adapt
    Agile
    Big Data
    CAS
    Complexity
    Context
    Culture
    Cynevin
    Data
    Disintermediation
    Distributed Cognition
    Foresight
    Future
    Granularity
    Growth Mindset
    Homo Economicus
    Innovation
    Knowledge
    Leadership
    Management
    Narrative
    Naturalisation
    Network
    Now Or Never
    OODA
    Organisational Health
    Power Maps
    Productivity
    Risk
    Russia
    Russian
    S Curve
    SenseMaker
    Sense-making
    Serendipity
    South Africa
    Strategy
    Technology
    Transformation
    Unintended Consequences
    Vector
    VUCA
    Weak Signals
    Workforce
    По-русски

© Narrative Insights (2014-2018)
marcusguest@narrativeinsights.com
​
+7 (915) 234 6653
"It ain't what you don't know that gets you in trouble; it's what you think you know for sure that just ain't so"

«Неприятности доставляет не то, о чем ты не знаешь,
а то, что, как тебе кажется, ты знаешь наверняка, но это не так»​
  • Русский
    • Формировать будущее
  • Cases
    • Shaping the Future
    • Capturing Market Share
    • Reducing Costs on Major Projects
    • Creating Agile Teams
    • Transforming the Banking Sector
    • Shaping the Future of Retail Banking
    • Three Strategies for Combating Amazon
  • About
    • О нас
  • Blog / Блог